Firearm physics
Seven checks a firearm's figures must pass because of physics rather than because of what other records say: the velocity its barrel can give, the energy its cartridge's pressure allows, the cartridge's name against its bullet, lengths that must nest, full recoil, a load's ballistic coefficient, and rifling twist. Each finding says what to do next, and Redback, the automatic review, the proposal repair and Quill all run the same module.
Velocity from barrel length
A load's published velocity comes from a known test barrel. A longer barrel lets the gas push the bullet further, so the velocity grows, but by less each time: a power of the distance the bullet travels. The cartridge's reference loads are scaled to this firearm's barrel, and the stated muzzle velocity must fall inside the band the exponents give.
where
- the muzzle velocity predicted for this barrel, m/s
- a reference load's velocity and the bullet travel of its test barrel
- bullet travel: the barrel less the case the bullet starts in, mm
- the exponent, from a short-barrel pistol to a magnum rifle
A figure within 8% of the band is not called suspect: loads and lots differ as much as barrels do.
M882 ball, 350 m/s from a 102 mm test barrel, scaled to a Glock 17's 114 mm barrel, against a recorded 360 m/s:
stated_mps = 360, predicted_mps = 362, band_low_mps = 329, band_high_mps = 399, barrel_mm = 114, loads_used = 1, implied_barrel_mm = 112
Inside: the figures agree.
On a suspect finding Redback reads the maker's own velocity for this barrel; the implied barrel length says whether the figure came from a longer or shorter one.
The pressure ceiling
The powder gas cannot do more work on the bullet than its peak pressure acting on the bore's area over the whole bullet travel. Real guns turn 20 to 45% of that ceiling into muzzle energy, because the pressure falls as the bullet moves.
where
- the muzzle energy, stated or from the bullet weight and velocity, J
- the cartridge's maximum pressure (C.I.P. or SAAMI), Pa
- the bullet diameter, m
Above 75% of the ceiling the figure is suspect; above the ceiling itself it is impossible.
An AK-pattern rifle, 415 mm barrel, 7.62x39mm at 355 MPa and 715 m/s:
energy_j = 2037, ceiling_j = 6581, share = 0.31, max_pressure_mpa = 355, bore_mm = 7.92
Inside: the figures agree.
An impossible finding means one of the energy, the velocity, the barrel or the cartridge is wrong; Redback checks the cartridge first, then re-reads the figures from the maker's page, and a proposal that keeps the figure is rejected.
Bore and cartridge
A cartridge's name states its bullet diameter (.308 is 0.308 in, 9 mm is 9 mm), and the cartridges one firearm lists must be close enough to share a barrel unless it is sold as a convertible.
where
- the diameter the cartridge's name states, mm
- the largest and smallest bullet among the firearm's cartridges, mm
The 7.62x39mm, whose 7.92 mm bullet is within the tolerance of its 7.62 name:
Inside: the figures agree.
A suspect finding is usually a cartridge attached to the wrong record, or a calibre record with a wrong diameter; Redback looks the cartridge up before using its figures.
Lengths that nest
The case sits inside the barrel and the barrel inside the gun, with room left for an action. A barrel as long as the whole gun is a unit slip or a swapped figure.
where
- the overall length, mm
The AK-pattern rifle: a 38.7 mm case in a 415 mm barrel in an 880 mm rifle:
barrel_mm = 415, overall_mm = 880, folded_mm = -, case_mm = 38.7
Inside: the figures agree.
An impossible finding is two figures in the wrong order or unit; Redback re-reads both lengths with their units.
Full recoil
Free recoil counts the powder gas as well as the bullet. The charge is estimated from the muzzle energy when the record does not state it: smokeless powder holds about 4 MJ/kg and about a third reaches the bullet.
where
- the gun's free recoil velocity, m/s
- the powder charge, estimated from the energy, kg
- SAAMI's gas velocity factor for the class of gun
The AK-pattern rifle at 3.47 kg, firing a 7.97 g bullet at 715 m/s:
recoil_velocity_mps = 2.25, recoil_energy_j = 8.8, impulse_ns = 7.82, charge_g_estimated = 1.7, weight_g = 3470
Inside: the figures agree.
A suspect finding is nearly always a weight in pounds or ounces read as kilograms; Redback re-reads the weight with its unit.
Ballistic coefficient
A bullet's G1 ballistic coefficient is its sectional density over a form factor, and real bullets have form factors in a narrow range. A coefficient far outside it belongs to another bullet or another drag model.
where
- the G1 form factor
- the sectional density, lb/in²
M882 ball, 8.04 g at 9.01 mm with a G1 coefficient of 0.149:
sectional_density = 0.141, bc_g1 = 0.149, form_factor = 0.95, bc_g7 = -
Inside: the figures agree.
A low coefficient is often a G7 figure filed as G1; Redback re-reads the coefficient with the drag model the page names.
Twist and stability
Greenhill's rule gives the slowest twist that spins a bullet of a given length and diameter fast enough to fly point first. A stated twist much slower than that cannot stabilise the cartridge's bullets.
where
- Greenhill's twist length, in calibres per turn
- the bullet's length in calibres, from its record or estimated from its weight
The AK-pattern rifle's 240 mm twist with 7.97 g bullets:
stated_twist_mm = 240, greenhill_twist_mm = 470, ratio = 0.51, bullet_length_mm = 20
Inside: the figures agree.
A suspect twist is usually in inches or turns per metre read as millimetres; Redback re-reads it with its unit.
Findings and what to do
Every finding is one of four verdicts and carries the action that settles it. Redback's physics_check tool prints the action as a Next line; the automatic review counts an impossible finding as a reject and a clean pass as an accept; the proposal repair sends a proposal back with the action in its note.
| # | When | Verdict | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A hard bound is broken | Impossible | The figure is not filed and a proposal is sent back; Redback re-reads the figures the action names. |
| 2 | Outside the predicted band | Review | Redback re-reads the figure the action names before filing it; the review does not count it either way. |
| 3 | Every method that ran agrees | Holds | Counts as a vote for the value in the automatic review. |
| 4 | A figure the method needs is missing | Set aside | No vote; the record's empty fields become gap tasks as usual. |